Files
edx-platform/common/lib/xmodule/xmodule/peer_grading_module.py
Chris Rossi 3256eb1ff6 Architecture for arbitrary field overrides, field overrides for
individual students, and a reimplementation of the individual due date
feature.

This work introduces an architecture, used with the 'authored_data'
portion of LmsFieldData, which allows arbitrary field overrides to be
made for fields that are part of the course content or settings (Mongo
data).  The basic architecture is extensible by means of writing and
configuring arbitrary field override providers.

One concrete implementation of a field override provider is provided
which allows for overrides to be for individual students.  This provider
is then used as a basis for reimplementing the individual due date
extensions feature as a proof of concept for the design.

One can imagine writing override providers that provide overrides based
on a student's membership in a cohort or other similar idea.  This work
is being done, in fact, to pave the way for the Personal Online Courses
feature being developed by MIT, which will use an override provider very
much long those lines.
2015-04-06 13:04:44 -07:00

712 lines
28 KiB
Python

import json
import logging
from datetime import datetime
from lxml import etree
from pkg_resources import resource_string
from xblock.fields import Dict, String, Scope, Boolean, Float, Reference
from xmodule.capa_module import ComplexEncoder
from xmodule.fields import Date, Timedelta
from xmodule.modulestore.exceptions import ItemNotFoundError, NoPathToItem
from xmodule.raw_module import RawDescriptor
from xmodule.timeinfo import TimeInfo
from xmodule.x_module import XModule, module_attr
from xmodule.open_ended_grading_classes.peer_grading_service import PeerGradingService, MockPeerGradingService
from open_ended_grading_classes import combined_open_ended_rubric
from django.utils.timezone import UTC
from xmodule.open_ended_grading_classes.grading_service_module import GradingServiceError
log = logging.getLogger(__name__)
# Make '_' a no-op so we can scrape strings
_ = lambda text: text
EXTERNAL_GRADER_NO_CONTACT_ERROR = "Failed to contact external graders. Please notify course staff."
MAX_ALLOWED_FEEDBACK_LENGTH = 5000
class PeerGradingFields(object):
use_for_single_location = Boolean(
display_name=_("Show Single Problem"),
help=_('When True, only the single problem specified by "Link to Problem Location" is shown. '
'When False, a panel is displayed with all problems available for peer grading.'),
default=False,
scope=Scope.settings
)
link_to_location = Reference(
display_name=_("Link to Problem Location"),
help=_('The location of the problem being graded. Only used when "Show Single Problem" is True.'),
default="",
scope=Scope.settings
)
graded = Boolean(
display_name=_("Graded"),
help=_('Defines whether the student gets credit for grading this problem. Only used when "Show Single Problem" is True.'),
default=False,
scope=Scope.settings
)
due = Date(
help=_("Due date that should be displayed."),
scope=Scope.settings)
graceperiod = Timedelta(
help=_("Amount of grace to give on the due date."),
scope=Scope.settings
)
student_data_for_location = Dict(
help=_("Student data for a given peer grading problem."),
scope=Scope.user_state
)
weight = Float(
display_name=_("Problem Weight"),
help=_("Defines the number of points each problem is worth. If the value is not set, each problem is worth one point."),
scope=Scope.settings, values={"min": 0, "step": ".1"},
default=1
)
display_name = String(
display_name=_("Display Name"),
help=_("Display name for this module"),
scope=Scope.settings,
default=_("Peer Grading Interface")
)
data = String(
help=_("Html contents to display for this module"),
default='<peergrading></peergrading>',
scope=Scope.content
)
class InvalidLinkLocation(Exception):
"""
Exception for the case in which a peer grading module tries to link to an invalid location.
"""
pass
class PeerGradingModule(PeerGradingFields, XModule):
"""
PeerGradingModule.__init__ takes the same arguments as xmodule.x_module:XModule.__init__
"""
_VERSION = 1
js = {
'coffee': [
resource_string(__name__, 'js/src/peergrading/peer_grading.coffee'),
resource_string(__name__, 'js/src/peergrading/peer_grading_problem.coffee'),
resource_string(__name__, 'js/src/javascript_loader.coffee'),
],
'js': [
resource_string(__name__, 'js/src/collapsible.js'),
]
}
js_module_name = "PeerGrading"
css = {'scss': [resource_string(__name__, 'css/combinedopenended/display.scss')]}
def __init__(self, *args, **kwargs):
super(PeerGradingModule, self).__init__(*args, **kwargs)
# Copy this to a new variable so that we can edit it if needed.
# We need to edit it if the linked module cannot be found, so
# we can revert to panel model.
self.use_for_single_location_local = self.use_for_single_location
# We need to set the location here so the child modules can use it.
self.runtime.set('location', self.location)
if (self.runtime.open_ended_grading_interface):
self.peer_gs = PeerGradingService(self.system.open_ended_grading_interface, self.system.render_template)
else:
self.peer_gs = MockPeerGradingService()
if self.use_for_single_location_local:
linked_descriptors = self.descriptor.get_required_module_descriptors()
if len(linked_descriptors) == 0:
error_msg = "Peer grading module {0} is trying to use single problem mode without "
"a location specified.".format(self.location)
log.error(error_msg)
# Change module over to panel mode from single problem mode.
self.use_for_single_location_local = False
else:
self.linked_problem = self.system.get_module(linked_descriptors[0])
try:
self.timeinfo = TimeInfo(self.due, self.graceperiod)
except Exception:
log.error("Error parsing due date information in location {0}".format(self.location))
raise
self.display_due_date = self.timeinfo.display_due_date
try:
self.student_data_for_location = json.loads(self.student_data_for_location)
except Exception: # pylint: disable=broad-except
# OK with this broad exception because we just want to continue on any error
pass
@property
def ajax_url(self):
"""
Returns the `ajax_url` from the system, with any trailing '/' stripped off.
"""
ajax_url = self.system.ajax_url
if not ajax_url.endswith("/"):
ajax_url += "/"
return ajax_url
def closed(self):
return self._closed(self.timeinfo)
def _closed(self, timeinfo):
if timeinfo.close_date is not None and datetime.now(UTC()) > timeinfo.close_date:
return True
return False
def _err_response(self, msg):
"""
Return a HttpResponse with a json dump with success=False, and the given error message.
"""
return {'success': False, 'error': msg}
def _check_required(self, data, required):
actual = set(data.keys())
missing = required - actual
if len(missing) > 0:
return False, "Missing required keys: {0}".format(', '.join(missing))
else:
return True, ""
def get_html(self):
"""
Needs to be implemented by inheritors. Renders the HTML that students see.
@return:
"""
if self.closed():
return self.peer_grading_closed()
if not self.use_for_single_location_local:
return self.peer_grading()
else:
# b/c handle_ajax expects serialized data payload and directly calls peer_grading
return self.peer_grading_problem({'location': self.link_to_location.to_deprecated_string()})['html']
def handle_ajax(self, dispatch, data):
"""
Needs to be implemented by child modules. Handles AJAX events.
@return:
"""
handlers = {
'get_next_submission': self.get_next_submission,
'show_calibration_essay': self.show_calibration_essay,
'is_student_calibrated': self.is_student_calibrated,
'save_grade': self.save_grade,
'save_calibration_essay': self.save_calibration_essay,
'problem': self.peer_grading_problem,
}
if dispatch not in handlers:
# This is a dev_facing_error
log.error("Cannot find {0} in handlers in handle_ajax function for open_ended_module.py".format(dispatch))
# This is a dev_facing_error
return json.dumps({'error': 'Error handling action. Please try again.', 'success': False})
data_dict = handlers[dispatch](data)
return json.dumps(data_dict, cls=ComplexEncoder)
def query_data_for_location(self, location):
student_id = self.system.anonymous_student_id
success = False
response = {}
try:
response = self.peer_gs.get_data_for_location(location, student_id)
_count_graded = response['count_graded']
_count_required = response['count_required']
success = True
except GradingServiceError:
# This is a dev_facing_error
log.exception("Error getting location data from controller for location %s, student %s", location, student_id)
return success, response
def get_progress(self):
pass
def get_score(self):
max_score = None
score = None
weight = self.weight
#The old default was None, so set to 1 if it is the old default weight
if weight is None:
weight = 1
score_dict = {
'score': score,
'total': max_score,
}
if not self.use_for_single_location_local or not self.graded:
return score_dict
try:
count_graded = self.student_data_for_location['count_graded']
count_required = self.student_data_for_location['count_required']
except:
success, response = self.query_data_for_location(self.link_to_location)
if not success:
log.exception(
"No instance data found and could not get data from controller for loc {0} student {1}".format(
self.system.location.to_deprecated_string(), self.system.anonymous_student_id
))
return None
count_graded = response['count_graded']
count_required = response['count_required']
if count_required > 0 and count_graded >= count_required:
# Ensures that once a student receives a final score for peer grading, that it does not change.
self.student_data_for_location = response
score = int(count_graded >= count_required and count_graded > 0) * float(weight)
total = float(weight)
score_dict['score'] = score
score_dict['total'] = total
return score_dict
def max_score(self):
''' Maximum score. Two notes:
* This is generic; in abstract, a problem could be 3/5 points on one
randomization, and 5/7 on another
'''
max_grade = None
if self.use_for_single_location_local and self.graded:
max_grade = self.weight
return max_grade
def get_next_submission(self, data):
"""
Makes a call to the grading controller for the next essay that should be graded
Returns a json dict with the following keys:
'success': bool
'submission_id': a unique identifier for the submission, to be passed back
with the grade.
'submission': the submission, rendered as read-only html for grading
'rubric': the rubric, also rendered as html.
'submission_key': a key associated with the submission for validation reasons
'error': if success is False, will have an error message with more info.
"""
required = set(['location'])
success, message = self._check_required(data, required)
if not success:
return self._err_response(message)
grader_id = self.system.anonymous_student_id
location = data['location']
try:
response = self.peer_gs.get_next_submission(location, grader_id)
return response
except GradingServiceError:
# This is a dev_facing_error
log.exception("Error getting next submission. server url: %s location: %s, grader_id: %s", self.peer_gs.url, location, grader_id)
# This is a student_facing_error
return {'success': False,
'error': EXTERNAL_GRADER_NO_CONTACT_ERROR}
def save_grade(self, data):
"""
Saves the grade of a given submission.
Input:
The request should have the following keys:
location - problem location
submission_id - id associated with this submission
submission_key - submission key given for validation purposes
score - the grade that was given to the submission
feedback - the feedback from the student
Returns
A json object with the following keys:
success: bool indicating whether the save was a success
error: if there was an error in the submission, this is the error message
"""
required = ['location', 'submission_id', 'submission_key', 'score', 'feedback', 'submission_flagged', 'answer_unknown']
if data.get("submission_flagged", False) in ["false", False, "False", "FALSE"]:
required.append("rubric_scores[]")
success, message = self._check_required(data, set(required))
if not success:
return self._err_response(message)
success, message = self._check_feedback_length(data)
if not success:
return self._err_response(message)
data_dict = {k: data.get(k) for k in required}
if 'rubric_scores[]' in required:
data_dict['rubric_scores'] = data.getall('rubric_scores[]')
data_dict['grader_id'] = self.system.anonymous_student_id
try:
response = self.peer_gs.save_grade(**data_dict)
success, location_data = self.query_data_for_location(data_dict['location'])
#Don't check for success above because the response = statement will raise the same Exception as the one
#that will cause success to be false.
response.update({'required_done': False})
if 'count_graded' in location_data and 'count_required' in location_data and int(location_data['count_graded']) >= int(location_data['count_required']):
response['required_done'] = True
return response
except GradingServiceError:
# This is a dev_facing_error
log.exception("Error saving grade to open ended grading service. server url: %s", self.peer_gs.url)
# This is a student_facing_error
return {
'success': False,
'error': EXTERNAL_GRADER_NO_CONTACT_ERROR
}
def is_student_calibrated(self, data):
"""
Calls the grading controller to see if the given student is calibrated
on the given problem
Input:
In the request, we need the following arguments:
location - problem location
Returns:
Json object with the following keys
success - bool indicating whether or not the call was successful
calibrated - true if the grader has fully calibrated and can now move on to grading
- false if the grader is still working on calibration problems
total_calibrated_on_so_far - the number of calibration essays for this problem
that this grader has graded
"""
required = set(['location'])
success, message = self._check_required(data, required)
if not success:
return self._err_response(message)
grader_id = self.system.anonymous_student_id
location = data['location']
try:
response = self.peer_gs.is_student_calibrated(location, grader_id)
return response
except GradingServiceError:
# This is a dev_facing_error
log.exception("Error from open ended grading service. server url: %s, grader_id: %s, location: %s", self.peer_gs.url, grader_id, location)
# This is a student_facing_error
return {
'success': False,
'error': EXTERNAL_GRADER_NO_CONTACT_ERROR
}
def show_calibration_essay(self, data):
"""
Fetch the next calibration essay from the grading controller and return it
Inputs:
In the request
location - problem location
Returns:
A json dict with the following keys
'success': bool
'submission_id': a unique identifier for the submission, to be passed back
with the grade.
'submission': the submission, rendered as read-only html for grading
'rubric': the rubric, also rendered as html.
'submission_key': a key associated with the submission for validation reasons
'error': if success is False, will have an error message with more info.
"""
required = set(['location'])
success, message = self._check_required(data, required)
if not success:
return self._err_response(message)
grader_id = self.system.anonymous_student_id
location = data['location']
try:
response = self.peer_gs.show_calibration_essay(location, grader_id)
return response
except GradingServiceError:
# This is a dev_facing_error
log.exception("Error from open ended grading service. server url: %s, location: %s", self.peer_gs.url, location)
# This is a student_facing_error
return {'success': False,
'error': EXTERNAL_GRADER_NO_CONTACT_ERROR}
# if we can't parse the rubric into HTML,
except etree.XMLSyntaxError:
# This is a dev_facing_error
log.exception("Cannot parse rubric string.")
# This is a student_facing_error
return {'success': False,
'error': 'Error displaying submission. Please notify course staff.'}
def save_calibration_essay(self, data):
"""
Saves the grader's grade of a given calibration.
Input:
The request should have the following keys:
location - problem location
submission_id - id associated with this submission
submission_key - submission key given for validation purposes
score - the grade that was given to the submission
feedback - the feedback from the student
Returns
A json object with the following keys:
success: bool indicating whether the save was a success
error: if there was an error in the submission, this is the error message
actual_score: the score that the instructor gave to this calibration essay
"""
required = set(['location', 'submission_id', 'submission_key', 'score', 'feedback', 'rubric_scores[]'])
success, message = self._check_required(data, required)
if not success:
return self._err_response(message)
data_dict = {k: data.get(k) for k in required}
data_dict['rubric_scores'] = data.getall('rubric_scores[]')
data_dict['student_id'] = self.system.anonymous_student_id
data_dict['calibration_essay_id'] = data_dict['submission_id']
try:
response = self.peer_gs.save_calibration_essay(**data_dict)
if 'actual_rubric' in response:
rubric_renderer = combined_open_ended_rubric.CombinedOpenEndedRubric(self.system.render_template, True)
response['actual_rubric'] = rubric_renderer.render_rubric(response['actual_rubric'])['html']
return response
except GradingServiceError:
# This is a dev_facing_error
log.exception("Error saving calibration grade")
# This is a student_facing_error
return self._err_response('There was an error saving your score. Please notify course staff.')
def peer_grading_closed(self):
'''
Show the Peer grading closed template
'''
html = self.system.render_template('peer_grading/peer_grading_closed.html', {
'use_for_single_location': self.use_for_single_location_local
})
return html
def _find_corresponding_module_for_location(self, location):
"""
Find the peer grading module that exists at the given location.
"""
try:
return self.descriptor.system.load_item(location)
except ItemNotFoundError:
# The linked problem doesn't exist.
log.error("Problem {0} does not exist in this course.".format(location))
raise
except NoPathToItem:
# The linked problem does not have a path to it (ie is in a draft or other strange state).
log.error("Cannot find a path to problem {0} in this course.".format(location))
raise
def peer_grading(self, _data=None):
'''
Show a peer grading interface
'''
# call problem list service
success = False
error_text = ""
problem_list = []
try:
problem_list_dict = self.peer_gs.get_problem_list(self.course_id, self.system.anonymous_student_id)
success = problem_list_dict['success']
if 'error' in problem_list_dict:
error_text = problem_list_dict['error']
problem_list = problem_list_dict['problem_list']
except GradingServiceError:
# This is a student_facing_error
error_text = EXTERNAL_GRADER_NO_CONTACT_ERROR
log.error(error_text)
success = False
# catch error if if the json loads fails
except ValueError:
# This is a student_facing_error
error_text = "Could not get list of problems to peer grade. Please notify course staff."
log.error(error_text)
success = False
except Exception:
log.exception("Could not contact peer grading service.")
success = False
good_problem_list = []
for problem in problem_list:
problem_location = problem['location']
try:
descriptor = self._find_corresponding_module_for_location(problem_location)
except (NoPathToItem, ItemNotFoundError):
continue
if descriptor:
problem['due'] = descriptor.due
grace_period = descriptor.graceperiod
try:
problem_timeinfo = TimeInfo(problem['due'], grace_period)
except Exception:
log.error("Malformed due date or grace period string for location {0}".format(problem_location))
raise
if self._closed(problem_timeinfo):
problem['closed'] = True
else:
problem['closed'] = False
else:
# if we can't find the due date, assume that it doesn't have one
problem['due'] = None
problem['closed'] = False
good_problem_list.append(problem)
ajax_url = self.ajax_url
html = self.system.render_template('peer_grading/peer_grading.html', {
'ajax_url': ajax_url,
'success': success,
'problem_list': good_problem_list,
'error_text': error_text,
# Checked above
'staff_access': False,
'use_single_location': self.use_for_single_location_local,
})
return html
def peer_grading_problem(self, data=None):
'''
Show individual problem interface
'''
if data is None or data.get('location') is None:
if not self.use_for_single_location_local:
# This is an error case, because it must be set to use a single location to be called without get parameters
# This is a dev_facing_error
log.error(
"Peer grading problem in peer_grading_module called with no get parameters, but use_for_single_location is False.")
return {'html': "", 'success': False}
problem_location = self.link_to_location
elif data.get('location') is not None:
problem_location = self.course_id.make_usage_key_from_deprecated_string(data.get('location'))
self._find_corresponding_module_for_location(problem_location)
ajax_url = self.ajax_url
html = self.system.render_template('peer_grading/peer_grading_problem.html', {
'view_html': '',
'problem_location': problem_location,
'course_id': self.course_id,
'ajax_url': ajax_url,
# Checked above
'staff_access': False,
'use_single_location': self.use_for_single_location_local,
})
return {'html': html, 'success': True}
def get_instance_state(self):
"""
Returns the current instance state. The module can be recreated from the instance state.
Input: None
Output: A dictionary containing the instance state.
"""
state = {
'student_data_for_location': self.student_data_for_location,
}
return json.dumps(state)
def _check_feedback_length(self, data):
feedback = data.get("feedback")
if feedback and len(feedback) > MAX_ALLOWED_FEEDBACK_LENGTH:
return False, "Feedback is too long, Max length is {0} characters.".format(
MAX_ALLOWED_FEEDBACK_LENGTH
)
else:
return True, ""
class PeerGradingDescriptor(PeerGradingFields, RawDescriptor):
"""
Module for adding peer grading questions
"""
mako_template = "widgets/raw-edit.html"
module_class = PeerGradingModule
filename_extension = "xml"
has_score = True
always_recalculate_grades = True
#Specify whether or not to pass in open ended interface
needs_open_ended_interface = True
metadata_translations = {
'is_graded': 'graded',
'attempts': 'max_attempts',
'due_data': 'due'
}
@property
def non_editable_metadata_fields(self):
non_editable_fields = super(PeerGradingDescriptor, self).non_editable_metadata_fields
non_editable_fields.extend([PeerGradingFields.due, PeerGradingFields.graceperiod])
return non_editable_fields
def get_required_module_descriptors(self):
"""
Returns a list of XModuleDescriptor instances upon which this module depends, but are
not children of this module.
"""
# If use_for_single_location is True, this is linked to an open ended problem.
if self.use_for_single_location:
# Try to load the linked module.
# If we can't load it, return empty list to avoid exceptions on progress page.
try:
linked_module = self.system.load_item(self.link_to_location)
return [linked_module]
except (NoPathToItem, ItemNotFoundError):
error_message = ("Cannot find the combined open ended module "
"at location {0} being linked to from peer "
"grading module {1}").format(self.link_to_location, self.location)
log.error(error_message)
return []
else:
return []
# Proxy to PeerGradingModule so that external callers don't have to know if they're working
# with a module or a descriptor
closed = module_attr('closed')
get_instance_state = module_attr('get_instance_state')
get_next_submission = module_attr('get_next_submission')
graded = module_attr('graded')
is_student_calibrated = module_attr('is_student_calibrated')
peer_grading = module_attr('peer_grading')
peer_grading_closed = module_attr('peer_grading_closed')
peer_grading_problem = module_attr('peer_grading_problem')
peer_gs = module_attr('peer_gs')
query_data_for_location = module_attr('query_data_for_location')
save_calibration_essay = module_attr('save_calibration_essay')
save_grade = module_attr('save_grade')
show_calibration_essay = module_attr('show_calibration_essay')
use_for_single_location_local = module_attr('use_for_single_location_local')
_find_corresponding_module_for_location = module_attr('_find_corresponding_module_for_location')